Supervisory control system



1950 E. VON MULINEN 2,509,850

SUPERVISORY CONTROL sys'rm Filed April 29, 194 4 She ets-Sheet 1 FiQl. l4 J /4 I2 6E I77 BM; 00 /29 ii K %%L@@O@@Q @M/MW,

am new.

May 30, 1950 E. VON EMULINEN SUPERVISORY CONTROL svs'rsm 4, Sheets-Sheet 2 Filed April 29, 1946 y 1950 E. VON MULINEN 2,509,850

suPERvIsoRY CONTROL SYSTEM Filed April 29, 1946 4 Sheets-Sheet s O O O O O O O O O O O O O O O O O O y 30, 1950 E. VON MULINEN 2,509,850

SUPERVISORY CONTROL SYSTEM Filed April 29, 1946 4 Sheets-Sheet 4 P59. 5, I we Eofafea in accordance #15 wif/v mm au/ed work 44 proyram of mac/line Eofefed as 0 fund/b aggr arm /riZI/he Illlllllll" /5/ mm? I W zrm $2M Elm/way.

Patented May 30, 1950 SUPERVISORY CONTROL SYSTEM Egbert von Miilinen, Ennetbaden, Switzerland Application April 29, 1946, Serial No. 665,881 In Switzerland May 16, 1945 6 Claims. 1

This invention relates to systems of supervisory control and more particularly to such systems of the comparison type.

An object of the invention is to provide a novel system of the character described wherein actual travel, progress, speed, advancement, production, position etc. of one or a plurality of interrelated operating components are automatically compared tvith a preselected program of operation for the components as related to time and any deviation therebetween is automatically signalled to a supervisor.

Another object is to provide a novel supervisory system wherein an observer at a central station may view the actual operating condition of a plurality of components such as working machines and the like as compared with a prearranged operating plan according to time.

Yet another object is to provide a novel panelboard system whereby an operator may, by means of light signals of different characteristics such as lights of different colors, flickering lights at different rates of flicker, etc., be informed as to the actual operating condition of one or a plurality of component machines as related to a predetermined desired program of operation.

A more specific object is to provide a novel supervisory system wherein the actual rate of production of a working machine is compared with a preplanned rate of production by means of switches advanced, respectively, with machine production and time, the switches being arranged in a signal circuit in such manner that a signal of one characteristic is conveyed to a supervisor when machine production is in step with planned production while a signal of a diiferent characteristic is conveyed to the supervisor when actual production of the machine either lags or leads the production plan.

These and other objects of the invention will become more apparent from the following detailed description of the invention as applied to diiierent types of operating components and accompanied by corresponding drawings.

In the drawings, Fig. 1 is a view in elevation of a portion of a panelboard on which the operator may view the signals, Fig. 2 is an electrical schematic of the switches and circuits by which the desired comparison may be made for one of a plurality of working machines whose production characteristics are viewed on the panelboard on Fig. 1; Fig. 3 shows a modified form of the switching arrangement of Fig. 2; Fig. 5 illustrates a somewhat different form of switching; Fig. 4 is an elevation of the type of panelboard to be 2 used with the switching system of Fig. 5; Fig. 6 is a diagrammatic view of a subway system incorporating the invention; while Fig. 7 is also a diagrammatic view of the invention as applied to a plant using the assembly line arrangement for manufacture.

In factories in which a number of working machines especially machine tools are set up, or which employ devices for assembly line manufacture for making certain products, it is most desirable that production for the machines be planned in advance so that all component parts produced by the machines will be available in suflicient quantities for subsequent assembly of the final product. Production planning alone will not suffice however and must be augmented by some suitable system for supervising actual production of each of the machines to determine how each is operating in relation to the overall production plan.

In the embodiments of the invention as illustrated by Figs, 1-5, supervision over the machines is maintained by use of a suitably located panelboard with which all of the machines are connected in such manner that actual production of each machine as compared with the scheduled production of such machine is indicated on the board by means of light signals. The arrangement is such that a light of one characteristic will indicate to the supervisor that a particular machine is producing at the preplanned rate while lights of different characteristics will indicate that the machine is either lagging or leading the scheduled plan for production. The electrical circuits and operating components thereof include a switching device for each of the machines which advances progressively as a function of the production of the machine, a master switching device which progresses in accordance with the planned production scheduled for such machine, means for continuously comparing the positions of the two switching devices for ascertaining any deviation therebetween, and means for operating the indicating lights on the panel in such a manner that the characteristic of the light is indicative of the production characteristics of the machine.

Referring now to the drawings and particularly to Figs. 1 and 2, a typical panelboard ID for supervising a plurality of working machines is shown in Fig. 1. This board is constituted by three sections ll, l2 and I3 placed side by side. The front surface of each of the sections ll, I2 and I3 is lined vertically to provide five columns I4, each of which represents a working machine in the plant. The surface of each section is also lined horizontally to divide the columns l4 into rectangular spaces l5 that are grouped into three sub-sections l8, I9 and 20. Each sub-section contains six spaces that are each representative of a period of machine production. Thus each of the sub-sections may denote a work week of six days for five machines. The spaces l5 of subsections IQ of the panelboard are transparent and each is arranged to be illuminated from the rear by means of lamps l6 suitably supported on the board and properly shielded from each other. The areas of the other sub-sections l8 and are not illuminated.

At the left side of the panelboard ID, the front surface is lined to provide another vertical column 2| and this column is also divided horizontally into rectangular spaces 22 which are grouped into three sections of six spaces each to denote the several work days of each week. The spaces of each section of column 2| may be numbered from one to six as shown and those of the middle section are transparent and are arranged to be illuminated from the rear by lamps 23.

In a manner to be more fully explained hereinafter, the lamps H5 in each of the columns ll of the middle sections is are arranged to be illuminated in succession by means of switches actuated by the machines as a, function of their production; and the lamps 23 in the middle section of the time column 2| are illuminated in succession by switches actuated in accordance with time. These switches are so interrelated that the particular characteristic of illumination of lamps l6 depends upon the relation between the amount of work actually performed by the machine during a period of time and the work scheduled in advance for such machine for such period as determined by the desired over-all production program for all machines in the plant. Details of one suitable switching arrangement for producing this result are to be found in Fig. 2 and these will be described later in detail.

As an example of a, typical operating condition of several machines, the lamp 23 behind the space numeralled 2" of the middle section of column 2| is lighted to indicate that the production program is in the'second day of the week. I! production of each of the fifteen machines (there may be more or less) is proceeding at the rate called for by the program, the switching devices on the machines will be in such position that the lamps it will be lighted in a row across the middle section l9 at the same level as lighted lamp 23.

In actual factory operation however, this optimum condition cannot always be maintained. Some machines might be working in advance of scheduled production while others might be lagging considerably in output. Thus, for example, the third machine (reading from left to right in the columns l4) might be working at a rate in advance of scheduled production and this would be indicated to the supervisor by a blinking lamp in the third space of the third row of the middle section. In a similar manner, a lag in production by the fifth machine would be indicated by a blinking lamp in the first space of the fifth row of this section. A lamp in the second space of the first row might blink at a different rate to indicate that number one machine has already completed its production assigned for the first day of the week and is preparing for that o! the second day.

The illuminated sections IQ of panelboard It thus serve to keep the supervisor informed as to the production of each machine for any current week. Unilluminated sections l8 and 20 of the board are not necessary if this is all the information that the supervisor desires. However these latter two sections are preferabh! included in order that production data may be posted over a three week period covering the past, current and coming weeks. For this purpose, interchangeable transparent glass plates 24, Zia and 2412 are provided and these are adapted to be placed on board Ill over a week's section of five machines. The surface of each plate is lined oil into thirty spaces corresponding to the spaces l5 over which the plate lies. Plate 24 over section l8 as shown in the drawint' has been inscribed with production data for the past week from which it can be seen that the article designated by the number "11 was made bythe first machine in the first two days of the past week, the article designated by the number 12" was made in the third day of that week by this machine, etc.

Plate 24a over section l9 would be inscribed with planned production data for the current week while plate 24b over section 20 would be inscribed with the plan of production for the coming week. At the end of the week, the plates would be shifted around. Plate 24 would be replaced by plate 24a; plate 24b would be moved up to the place formerly occupied by plate 24a; and plate 24 would be put in the place previously occupied by plate 24b. The inscriptions on plate 24 would then be erased and the production plan for the machines for the next new week reinscribed thereon.

If desired, a permanent record of the operation of each machine may be obtained at the supervisory control station by means of recording instruments which trace two records 25, 26 on a moving chart 2'! for each machine. The chart 2'! is viewed through a window 28 in the control panel. One record relates to production data While the other relates to starting and stopping of the machines. By special recording pens, the regularity of the course of production can be recorded. The records so made by all the recording pens can be used very well for making wagepayment calculations.

The panelboard l0 may also be provided with a set of two signal lamps 3|, 32 for each machine. One lamp of each set would be lit while the machine was out of operation and the others while the machine was in operation.

Reference is now made to Fig. 2 which shows a suitable circuit arrangement for setting up on panelboard ID the light signals of various characteristics dependent upon the relation between actual and pre-planned production for a machine.

It has already been stated that the lights of different characteristic on the panelboard Ill are indicative to the supervisor of the production characteristic of each machine in the plant under supervision and that the particular light characteristic displayed is determined by the relation between two switching devices, one of which is actuated by the machine as a function of its production and the other by a timing device set up in accordance wtih the production plan for such machine.

Thus referring now to Fig. 2, the master switching device actuated as a function of planned production for the six illustrated time periods is shown generally by the parts within the block 33. and is comprised of six switch sections 3439.

Each section of the switch, such as section 34 for example, includes a pivoted arm 34a mounted on a shaft 4| and as the latter rotates, arm 34a wipes over an arcuate path for contact with either an elongated arcuate segment 34!) or a point contact 34c, both of which are stationary. The other switch arms 35ar38a move with arm 34a as the shaft 4| rotates. Rotation of shaft 4| is effected in steps of equal angular displacement by means of an electromagnetic motor comprising solenoid winding 42 and armature 43 having a pawl 44 that engages a ratchet wheel 45 which is suitably keyed to shaft 4|. Energization of winding 42 occurs periodically as a. function of time determined by suitable means such as clockwork controlled switch mechanism of conventional construction and therefore indicated generally by the block symbol 46.

The stepped rotation of shaft 4| is so arranged that with each movement thereof, the arms of the several switch sections 34--39 engage their point contacts in succession. Thus, for example, during one time period, arm 35a engages contact 350; when the end of that period occurs, shaft 4| rotates to bring arm 36a into engagement with point contact 360, and so forth. It should be noted that the point and segmental contact elements of the switch sections 34-38 are so staggered angularly that the switch arms engage the point contact element at different angular positions and at such positions only. At all other angular positions of these arms, they make contact with a portion of the arcuate segmental contact element. Such arrangement requires the four inside segmental contacts 35b- 38b to be split or interrupted as shown with their respective "point contacts 350-380 located in the space between the split sections, while the outer segmental contacts 342) and 39b are continuous for their entire length.

The arcuate contact segments 34b-39b are connected by conductors to the positive side of v a source of current designated by conventional symbols through a current interrupter device 52 which includes contacts 53 opened and closed at a comparatively rapid rate by projections 54 on a disc 55 that is rotated by motor 56.

The point contacts 34c39c are connected by conductors 51 to the positive side of a source of steady or uninterrupted current.

It will now be evident that as the several arms 34a-39a come successively into engagement with their associated point contact elements 340- 39c, steady power will be put on outgoing lines 58-83 connected to these arms. At all other times, i. e. when arms 34a39a engage their respectlve arcuate contacts 34b-39b rapidly interrupted or flickering" power will be put out to lines 58-453.

Also associated with the master switch mechanism is still another set of stationary contacts 65 which are adapted to be wiped in succession by a contactor arm 65 which is connected to the positive side of a power source. The several contacts 65 have the same angular spacing as contacts 34c--39c and function to pass current in succession over lines 61 to the vertical bank of time period lamps 23 previously described.

The switching apparatus that is actuated as a function of actual production of the machine, as distinguished from its planned production, is contained generally within the block 68 and comprises a step relay 89 that includes a pair of coupled arms 10, H which are progressively stepped nzether over their respectively associated fixed sets of contacts 18a, Ha. Contactor arms 18, II are stepped up from one contact to another each time that solenoid winding 12 is energized, the armature element 13 of the solenoid being mechanically linked to coupled arms I8, II by pawl 14, ratchet wheel 14a and shaft 15.

Also included is a switch arm 16 that is moved upward momentarily from fixed contact 16a each time the amount of production assigned for one time period, as determined by the production plan, is completed by the machine. As arm 18 moves upward, it strikes against one end of a pivotally supported arm 1617 which causes the other end thereof to move downwardly and momentarily engage fixed contact 160. When this occurs, it will be seen from the drawing that solenoid winding 12 is energized for the brief period that arm 18b remains engaged with fixed contact 16c over a circuit which may be traced from the positive side of a power source over conductors 11, 18, arm 16b, contact 16c and conductor I9. Arm 16b is otherwise maintained in the position shown in Fig. 2 by spring 8|.

Also associated with the working machine is another switch arm 82 that is closed when the machine is operating and open when it is shut down. The arrangements by which switch arms 15 and 82 are actuated by the machine have not been illustrated since these will vary for different types of machines and are well within the skill of an artisan in this field.

A further component of the switching mechanism associated with each machine includes a relay 83 having two sets of contacts 83a, 83b. The winding 830 of this relay is connected via conductor 9| to fixed contact 16a and is energized during the time that arm 16 is engaged with this contact.

When relay 83 is energized, the set of contacts 83a are electrically connected by conductive bridge 83d to thereby close a circuit between the two coupled arms 10, H of the step relay. When relay 83 is deenergized, the other set of contacts 83b are electrically connected by bridge 83d to thereby connect arm 1| via conductor 88 to the positive side of a source of current designated by conventional symbol through a current interrupter device 84 which includes contacts 85 that are opened and closed at a comparatively slow rate by projections 88 on a disc 81 that is rotated by motor 88.

For indicating on and oil conditions of the machine, there is provided a relay 92 having two sets of contacts 92a, 92b. The coil 920 for this relay is connected via conductor 93 and switch arm 82 to the positive side of a source of power. Thus when the machine is operating and switch arm 82 is accordingly closed, relay 92 is energized to close a power circuit through its set of contacts 92a and conductor 88 to signal lamp 32 on the front of panelboard l0. When the machine is out of operation and switch arm 82 is open, relay 82 is deenergized and thus closes a power circuit through its other set of contacts 921) and conductor 98 to the adjacent signal lamp 3| on panelboard "I.

As previously explained, operating characteristics of the machine may also be permanently recorded. Thus each machine may be provided with two recording pens 95, 88 that are actuated by coils 85a, 86a respectively.

Coil 85a is energized from a power source whenever switch arm 82 is closed, this coil being connected via conductor 84 into the same circuit as relay winding 82c, and the pen 85 thus traces '7 the line 28 on moving chart 21 which is visible through window 28 on panelboard III to record the fact that the machine is in operation. Whenever the machine is stopped, coil 95a becomes deenergized. and pen 85 shifts transversely to thereby likewise displace the recorded trace 2!.

Coil 98a is energized from a power source during the time that switch arm 18 is engaged with contact 18a. this coil being connected via conductor 88 into the same circuit as relay winding 83c, and thus pen 86 traces the line 26 on chart 21 to record this condition. Now, whenever the machine completes the preselected amount of production and switch arm 18 moves upwardly, coil 86a is deenergized and pen 88 is jogged transversely on chart 21 to record this fact.

The master switch 38 which is advanced periodically with time is electrically interconnected with the step relay 58 that is advanced periodically in accordance with actual production of the machine in such manner that when machine production is in step with planned production, the lamps IS in the vertical lamp bank I4 on panelboard I representing that machine receive in succession "steady" power. But when machine production either lags or leads the planned production schedule. lamps I8 receive flickering power. This is accomplished by connecting the outgoing lines 58-63 in succession to successive contacts of the contact set 10a. of the step relay 9 that periodically advances contactor arms 10, 1| one step each time that the machine completes the amount of production preplanned for the production period, and by connecting the contacts of contact set 1Ia in succession via conductors IIlI-Ill8 to the lamps l6.

As illustrated, the machine is working in the second period of production and the production program is likewise in the second period. Hence machine production agrees with planned production and the second lamp in the lamp column I4 is illuminated "steadily over a circuit that may be traced from conductor 51, contact 85c, contactor arm 35a, conductor 59, the second contact element on contact set -Illa, contactor arm 10, relay contacts 83a, contactor arm II, the second contact of contact set Na and conductor I 02 to the second lamp I6 from the top in column I4.

If machine production is not in agreement with planned production, for example the machine is lagging and. still working in the first period of production, arms 10 and H would then be on the first contacts of contact sets 18a and Ho, respectively, and hence the top lamp it of the lamp row ll would receive "flickering" power from the current interrupter 52 via conductor contact segment 34b, contact arm a, conductor 58, the first contact on contact set a, contactor arm 10, relay contacts 83a, contactor arm 1|, the first of the contacts on contact set He and conductor IIII.

'If machine production were to be leading the planned production, the third lamp I6 in row It would be similarly supplied with flickering power.

As the machine completes an amount of production planned for one period of time, switch arm 16 is tripped for a brief period causing relay coil 12 to become energized and step contactor arms 10, 1| to the next contact position. Also for the period that switch arm 16 is disengaged from contact 18a, relay 83 is deenergized and the source of slowly flickering power from contacts ll of the current interrupter 84 is completed to 8 the next lower lamp I8 via relay contacts 88b to thus indicate this fact to the supervisor.

In order to initially synchronize the switch mechanisms, a manually operated push button switch I 01 may be associated with step relay 68 to step it around independently of operation of the switch 16 controlled by the machine.

While the switching mechanism 68 for only one working machine has been illustrated, the other machines in the group being supervised would be provided with similar switch mechanisms and these would be similarly connected to the outgoing lines 5863 of the master switch mechanism 83.

Fig. 8 illustrates a modified construction for the switching mechanism actuated as a function of the actual production of the machine to light the lamps of the time periods of one time section plus a few more in the preceding time section and a like number in the next following time section, as distinguished from the Fig. 1 arrangement where the lamps for only one time section are illuminated. In Fig. 3, the time section I8 has been illustrated as comprising ten time periods with an overlap of three time periods each in the last and next time sections I8a', I8b' to permit a maximum time differential between several machines (from a viewpoint of production) of not more than four time periods.

Instead of two switch arms as provided in the step relay 69 of Fig. 2, the step relay 69' has four coupled arms I20-I23 that are stepped up one contact at a time each time that relay winding 12' is energized. The fixed contacts I 20a are connected to incoming lines I24 from the output of the switching mechanism associated with the planned production; it would be similar to the mechanism shown within the block 33 in Fig. 2 and hence has not been illustrated. The control for periodic energization of relay winding 12' in accordance with actual production of the machine would likewise be similar to that shown in Fig. 2 and is therefore also not shown here.

The fourth to the seventh fixed contacts (from the top down) of contact set I2Ia are connected to the signal lamps in boxes numbered 4 to 7 of the middle time section I8; the first and last three contacts of set I22a are connected, respectively, to the signal lamps in boxes numbered 1 to 3 of the middle time section I8" and signals 8 to III of the preceding time section Ilia; and the first and last three fixed contacts of set I23a are connected, respectively to signal lamps in boxes numbered 1 to 3 of the next time section I8b' and lamps in boxes numbered 8 to 10 of the middle time section I8.

Arms I20 and I2I are interconnected via conductors I25, I26, switch I21 and relay contacts 83a, these being closed when relay winding 830' is energized in the same manner as relay winding 830 in Fig. 2.. The other set of relay contacts 83b connect via conductor I28 to a source of power through a current interrupting device of the same construction as interrupter 84 of Fig. 2 and which has therefore been omitted for the sake of simplicity.

Switch arms I20 and I22 are connected through relay contacts 83a and a single pole, double throw switch I29 when its blade I290 engages fixed contact I29b. Switch arms I20 and I23 are similarly connected when blade I29a is thrown to engage contact I290.

With the arrangement in Fig. 3, if not all of the machines are producing at exactly the rate set up by the program, the supervisor must be able to carry over to a newly starting time section, a visual indication of any machine whose production does not agree with the program. This, he accomplishes by actuating the switch I29. For example, if the machine is behind at the end of thetenth period of a time section, such that it is then only in its eighth period of production, switch blade I29a can then be thrown to contact I29b to transfer the visual indication from the eighth box in time section I8 to the 8th box in section I8a.

If the machine should happen to be ahead of scheduled production at the end of a time section, for example the lamp is lit in box "3 of section I8b', then when the light in the time column is switched back to indicate the first time period of a new time section, switch blade I29a can also be thrown to contact I29b to transfer visual indication to box 3 of section I8.

If the machine is running according to schedule, switch blade I290. remains in contact with contact I291) throughout the indications for the first seven time periods of a time section but must be thrown to contact I290 to get the proper indications for the last three time periods. When a new time section begins, switch arm I29a, is thrown back into engagement with contact I29b and the visual indication cycle is thus repeated.

An embodiment of the invention which affords a continuous indication of the relationship between the actual and the planned production of a plurality of machines is illustrated in Figs. 4 and 5. The panelboard I is divided vertically into ten columns which each denote a machine, and each column is made up of twelve boxes I5 which represent successive time periods during which each machine is scheduled to produce a preselected number of articles or a preselected length of web material, for example paper, wall board or textile fabrics. The panel surface is of translucent or transparent material, and lamps: IS in the several boxes I5 are energized (but only one at a time in each column) in accordance with the actual production of the machines. Pairs of signal lamps 3i, 32' are located below each column and controlled, as described with reference to Fig. 2, to indicate whether or not the machines are in operation. Push knobs I40 are arranged below the pairs of signal lamps for, manual operation, as will be described later, when the machines complete the preselected volume of work for one time period. The lamps I 6' of each column are energized in succession. as in the previously described forms of the invention, as the several machines complete the work scheduled for success ve time periods.

The panelboard I0 is also provided with luminous strips I4Ia which supplement the step-bystep indications of the lamps l6 by visual indications of the accumulated output or performance of each machine with respect to its scheduled output. A measuring instrument HI and lamp I4Ib control the color display on the luminous strips I4Ia, the associated network for determining the color presentation in accordance with the relation between elapsed time and actual production being shown in Fig. 5. The full length of each strip I 4Ia is illuminated by white light when the associated machine is operating on schedule, but more or less of each strip appears in color when the machine production lags or leads the preselected output for the elapsed time. The voltage which is impressed upon the moving coil Id of the measuring instrument is derived from two voltage dividers, one voltage divider being continuously adjusted on a time basis and the other being adjusted in accordance with the actual production of the associated machine. The rates of voltage change at the two voltage dividers are constant and equal so long as the machine maintains its scheduled rate of production, but the significant voltages drawn from the voltage dividers for comparison by the measuring instrument depart from equality when the machine output lags'or leads the scheduled production.

Referring now to Fig.' 5, the switching mechanism actuated in accordance with the production plan for the machine is comprised of a ring type voltage distributing resistor or potentiometer I42 connected at its end terminals to a source of voltage indicated by the usual symbols, and divided into three equal sections I 42a, I42?) and I420. Three equally spaced arms I43 are mounted on shaft I44 for rotation as a unit in the direction shown, by a synchronous motor I45 through reduction gearing (not shown) to wipe over the segments of resistor I42 at a rate established in accordance with the planned production or work.

The switching mechanism actuated in accordance with production of the machine is comprised of a, ring type voltage dividing resistor or potentiometer I 46 that is connected across the intermediate section I42b of resistor I42 by conductors I41, I48. A contact arm I49 is rotated over the resistor I46 in accordance with the production of the associated machine, and the moving coil I 4| d of instrument MI is connected between the contact arm I49 and one of the rotating contact arms I43 of the "scheduled production resistor I42, as will be described in detail hereinafter. The contact arm I49 starts at one end of the resistor I46 at the beginning of a time period and is advanced clockwise to make one full rotation as the machine performs the work scheduled for the time period.

A circuit for visually indicating the completion of the scheduled work is momentarily energized by a switch arm I5I which is pivotally mounted for actuat on bv the contact arm I49 as it completes a full rotation, the switch arm I5I being thus momentarily rocked into engagement with a contact I5Ia. The circuit extends from the positive side of a power source, through the switch I5I, I5Ia. a lead I52, and the winding I530 of a relay I53. On energization of relay I53, the double bridge contacts I53b are engaged with the front contacts I53c and the holding circuit contacts I53d respectively. The positive terminal of the holding contacts is connected by a jumper to one of the back contacts I53e through which direct current is normally supplied for the steady illumination of the lamp I4Ib which is associated with the measuring instrument. On energization of the relav I53, the front contacts I530 connect the lamp I4Ib to the current source through a switch I 54 which is opened and closed cyclically by a cam I55 driven by a motor I56.

The illumination at the panel I4Ia is changed from a steady to a flickering illumination at the completion of a unit quantity of work, and the supervisor then depresses the associated pushbutton I40 to open the single pole, double throw switch I51 in the holding circuit of the relay I53. The relay armature drops out to reclose its back contacts, thereby supplying steady current to lamp I4Ib upon the release of the pushbutton.

As noted above, the color display on the several luminous strips I4Ia changes in accordance with the relative magnitudes of two voltages which 11 vary with scheduled production and actual production, respectively, and which are compared by the instrument I. The staff of the instrument carries an arcuately shaped transparent or translucent band I58 which isdivided into three sections I58a, I58?) and I 58c which transmit red," white and green light, respectively. The moving coil id is connected to the arm I49 of resistor I46 by a lead I6I, and to the rotating arms I43 of the resistor I42 through a lead I62 and a three-point switch I63 comprising a switch arm I63a and contacts I632) connected to the several rotating arms I43 of the voltage divider I42. The switch arm I63a is moved counterclockwise, step-by-step, by successive energizations of a solenoid I630 upon shifting of switch I51 by the manually operated pushbutton I 40.

The circuit arrangements for eflecting the successive energization of the several lamps I6 01' a column includes a contact arm I64 on the staff of instrument HI and a contact I64a which is connected through lead I65 to a stepping switch I66, which controls the energization of the individual leads I61 to the several lamps I6. The stepping switch includes a solenoid I661: having an armature I661) carrying a pawl I66c cooperating with ratchet wheel I66d on shaft I66e of the switch arm I66) which sweeps over contacts I660.

The voltage drop across the moving coil I4Id of instrument MI is abruptly shifted by onethird the source voltage when the contact arm I49 moves from one end to the other of resistor I46 upon the completion of the scheduled work for one time period, and the moving coil I 11 is thereby displaced angularly to close the contact arm I64 on contact I64a to energize the stepping switch to light the next lamp I6. This abrupt displacement of the moving coil I4Id moves the "red" section I58a of the band I58 into line with the lamp ID, and this adjustment of the band I58 would normally indicate a lag in production. At the same time, however. the rotat ing arm I49 moves the switch arm II into engagement with contact I 5Ia to energize the relay I 53 and thereby supply a pulsating current to the lamp "lb. The flickering illumination of the light strip advises the supervisor that the machine has completed a preselected un t volume of work and that the pushbutton I40 should be depressed to advance the three-point switch I63 one. step and to restore a steady current supply to the lamp I M b.

Upon advancing the switch I63 one step, the return connection I62 from the instrument MI is made to a voltage point on the resistor I42 which is less than the previous return voltage by one-third the source voltage. The circuit connections are thus re-established for a comparison of voltages representing scheduled production and actual production.

For any given operating period of the machine, if machine production agrees with planned production, the contactor arm I49 will be driven at such an angular rate that it completes one revolution for each one-third revolution of the contactor arms I43. Further, the relative angular positions of arms I49 and I43 are initially so selected that under the aforesaid condition of operation, the voltage taken off arm I49 opposes and is always equal in magnitude to the voltage taken off that one of the arms I43 which is then connected to switch arm I63a. Thus no current flows through coil I4Id oi the "zero center instrument MI and the band I" occupies a central position with respect 12 to lamp I4Ib such that nothing but white light appears in the light strip I4Ia.

Should machine production lag the planned production, the voltage on arm I49 will no longer 5 be equal to that at switch arm I63c and hence current will flow through coil I4Id in such direction as to cause band I56 to turn counterclockwise and bring a portion of the "red band section I 56a into view at the top of the light strip Mia. The length of the red section seen in the strip will vary with the amount of unbalance in voltage and hence will be representative of the extent that the machine is lagging in production. Should machine production lead the planned production, the unbalance in voltage between arm I49 and switch arm I63a is reversed and hence band I58 turns clockwise to display a portion of the "green section I56c at the bottom of the light strip I4Ia.

These two conditions of lag and lead for diil'erent machines might appear as shown, respectively, by strips I4Ia' and "la" in Fig. 4.

In Fig. 6, application of the invention is made to an arrangement for supervising trafllc in a subway transit system. In this embodiment,

the track system is reproduced on a panelboard and, as illustrated, comprises two double track lines I15, I16 with stations therealong designated by the small, substantially square areas and track blocks by the larger elongated areas. Each track block and station could be represented on the panelboard by an indicator of the luminous image type. The departure and travel times of the different trains are checked continuously, and switching devices actuated respectively in accordance with time and with the trafiic plan to be maintained are provided. Also in certain cases, switches actuated as trains pass selected control points will have to be provided. Thus for example, if the dispatching of a train at station I11 has been very greatly delayed, red blinking light would appear. Too long a stay in block section I18 would likewise be indicated by red blinking light. A slight delay of trains at stations I19, I80 and track blocks I8I, I62 would be indicated by a steady red light in each of these areas.

In the arrangement shown in Fig. 6, necessary different types of indications for each station and track section may be obtained by switching to diflerent lamps or by using indicators of the general type shown in Fig. 5. If the latter type are used, the amount of the delays and thus the deviation in actual tramc flow from a predetermined trafllc program can be expressed by the length of the colored image.

In Fig. '1, the invention is applied to a panelboard type of supervision for an assembly line, the sections of which are represented on the 00 board in the form of areas adapted to be illuminated.

Areas designated by numerals I84-I9!I denote feeder sections to the main assembly line I9I. A delay of material or parts in any of the feeder 65 sections, such as in sections I96, I81, would be indicated by a red warning light. Areas designated by numerals I 92I 96 correspond to storage points and too great a reduction in stock at any of these points such as that represented by area 7 I95 would be indicated by red blinking light. A slight delay at the lower end I9I' of the main assembly line I9l would be indicated by a red light while on greater delay, the red light here might change from steady to blinking. 7 In conclusion, it is to be understood that while 13 preferred constructions of the invention have been shown and described, various changes and modifications may occur to those skilled in the art and may be made without departing from the spirit and scope of the appended claims. I

I claim:

1. In a system for supervising the operation of a working machine and the like, means producing a first potential variable in accordance with time, means producing a second potential variable in accordance with the progress of said machine, circuit means connecting said potentials in opposition, and an electrical measuring instrument connected in said circuit means and which includes a moving system displaceable in accordance with the extent of the unbalance between said potentials.

2. A supervisory system as defined in claim 1 wherein said potentials become unbalanced to a predetermined maximum upon completion of a unit 01' progress 0! said machine and further including, a row of light signals each indicative ,of a unit of progress of said machine, and means controlled by the moving system of said instrument for illuminating said signals in succession. 3. In a system for supervising the operation or a working machine and the like, means deriving a first potential that varies with time, means producing a second potential that varies with production of said machine, circuit means conmeeting said potentials in opposition, and instrument means connected in said circuit means for indicating the sense and magnitude 0! any unbalance between said potentials.

4.Asupervisorysystemasdefinedinclaim 3 wherein said instrument means is of the luminous band type comprising a light strip, a light source, and a multi-colored hand between 14 said strip and source and which is displaceable with respect to said light strip in accordance with the difference between said potentials.

5. In a visual system for observing actual progress of a device such as a working machine and the like as compared with a predetermined plan of operation as related to time, a pair of potentiometers, time controlled means advancing one of said potentiometers, machine progress controlled means advancing the other potentiometer, circuit means connecting said potentiometers in opposition, and a visual signal device connected in said circuit means, said signal device including an indicator movable from a center zero position in accordance with the direction and magnitude of current in said circuit means.

6. An observation system as defined in claim 5 wherein said signal device comprises a-measuring instrument including a light source, a, light strip, and a multi-colored band located between said strip and source and which is displaceable with respect to said light strip to alter the color of one part of the latter when said current flow is in one direction and to alter the color of another part of said strip when said current fiow is in the opposite direction.

EGBERT you MULmEN.

REFERENCES CITED The following references are of record in the file of this patent:

UNITED STATES PATENTS Name Date Scheiiler Jan. 11, 1927 Boedtcher Nov. 22, 1932 Hershey Apr. 30, 1935 Jackes June 17, 194'! Number 

